These terms apply to ICFJE Reviewers and to members of a journal's evaluation committee. They apply in addition to the General Terms of Use.
1. Your role
You evaluate journals against the 100 published ICFJE criteria, scoring each from 0 to 5, using the journal's website, published issues and policies.
2. Integrity
- Score honestly and independently, based on evidence, and apply the criteria in the same way to every journal.
- Declare any conflict of interest and do not review that journal. Conflicts include being, or in the last three years having been, its editor, board member, author of several of its recent articles, employee or paid consultant, or having a close personal or financial relationship with its publisher.
- Do not accept gifts, payments, authorship offers or other favours from journals or publishers in connection with an evaluation.
- Do not discuss your scores with the journal or with other reviewers before they are published.
3. Confidentiality
Applications, unpublished reviews, fast-track orders and anything else you see in the dashboard that is not public are confidential, during and after your term.
4. Moderation
Your reviews may be checked by an administrator before publication. ICFJE may correct errors in data, unpublish a review or end your reviewer role if these terms are breached.
5. Voluntary role
Unless agreed otherwise in writing, the reviewer role is voluntary and unpaid and does not create employment.