ICFJEInternational Consortium of Forensic Journal Editors

ICFJE evaluation criteria

One hundred criteria in ten domains, each scored from 0 (not met) to 5 (excellent).

1 Editorial Governance and Board

Who runs the journal, how independent and qualified they are.

  1. C001 The Editor-in-Chief is a recognised subject expert, with full name, affiliation and verifiable credentials published.
  2. C002 The editorial board lists full names, designations, affiliations and countries of all members.
  3. C003 The board draws members from at least three institutions and includes international representation.
  4. C004 Board members have a demonstrable publication record in forensic medicine, forensic science or allied fields.
  5. C005 Roles and responsibilities of editors, section editors and board members are defined and published.
  6. C006 The editorial board is reviewed and renewed at defined intervals.
  7. C007 Ownership of the journal and the publisher or managing society are clearly stated.
  8. C008 Editorial decisions are demonstrably independent of owners, sponsors and advertisers.
  9. C009 A working editorial office contact (email and postal address) is published and responds to queries.
  10. C010 Editors and board members declare their competing interests.

2 Peer Review Process

How rigorously and transparently manuscripts are reviewed.

  1. C011 Every research article undergoes documented peer review by at least two independent external reviewers.
  2. C012 The type of peer review (single-blind, double-blind or open) is clearly stated.
  3. C013 Guidelines for reviewers are published.
  4. C014 Reviewers are selected for subject expertise and a reviewer database is maintained.
  5. C015 Editors and reviewers handling a manuscript have no conflict of interest with its authors.
  6. C016 Submission, acceptance and publication dates are displayed on each article.
  7. C017 Time from submission to first decision is reasonable (8 weeks or less) and disclosed.
  8. C018 Authors receive reviewer comments and an opportunity to respond to them.
  9. C019 An appeals and complaints process for editorial decisions is published.
  10. C020 Reviewers are acknowledged, for example by an annual list or recognised reviewer credit.

3 Publication Ethics and Integrity

Adherence to COPE/ICMJE principles and handling of misconduct.

  1. C021 The journal explicitly follows COPE and ICMJE recommendations.
  2. C022 All submissions are screened for plagiarism with a named tool and a stated similarity policy.
  3. C023 Ethics committee approval and informed consent are required for human, animal and cadaveric research.
  4. C024 There is a policy on confidentiality and anonymisation of case reports, autopsy and medico-legal data.
  5. C025 Authorship criteria and contributor roles are defined.
  6. C026 Conflict of interest and funding statements are required for every article.
  7. C027 Corrections, retractions and expressions of concern are handled and published following COPE.
  8. C028 There is a policy for handling data fabrication, falsification, image manipulation and other misconduct.
  9. C029 There is a policy on the use of AI tools by authors, reviewers and editors.
  10. C030 There is no evidence of predatory practices such as spam solicitation, guaranteed acceptance or fake metrics.

4 Publishing Regularity and Timeliness

Whether the journal appears on schedule and without gaps.

  1. C031 Issues have been published on the stated schedule, without gaps, for the last three years.
  2. C032 The publication frequency is clearly declared.
  3. C033 The journal has a continuous publication history of at least two years.
  4. C034 The number of articles per issue and per year is consistent, without unexplained spikes.
  5. C035 Every issue in the archive is complete; there are no empty or missing issues.
  6. C036 Accepted articles are published within a reasonable time (six months or less).
  7. C037 An online-first or ahead-of-print policy is stated where applicable.
  8. C038 Special issues have a guest-editor policy and follow the same review standards.
  9. C039 Volume and issue numbering is consistent.
  10. C040 The journal publishes an annual editorial or report on its performance.

5 Scientific Quality and Forensic Relevance

Quality of published science and its fit with forensic disciplines.

  1. C041 Published content falls clearly within forensic medicine, forensic science, toxicology, medical law or allied sciences.
  2. C042 Aims and scope are precisely defined and matched by the published content.
  3. C043 Original research makes up a substantial share (50% or more) of published content.
  4. C044 Articles show sound methodology, appropriate statistics and conclusions supported by data.
  5. C045 Abstracts are structured and informative, and keywords are provided.
  6. C046 References are current, relevant and correctly formatted.
  7. C047 Reporting guidelines (CONSORT, STROBE, CARE, PRISMA and similar) are recommended or enforced.
  8. C048 Language editing and copy-editing are of high quality.
  9. C049 Authors come from many institutions and regions, not mainly from the board or one institution.
  10. C050 Journal self-citation is within reasonable limits.

6 Transparency, Policies and Author Guidance

Clarity of the rules authors and readers rely on.

  1. C051 Comprehensive instructions for authors are published (article types, format, referencing).
  2. C052 All fees (APC, submission, fast-track) are declared before submission, with a waiver policy.
  3. C053 Copyright and licensing terms are clearly stated.
  4. C054 A privacy statement covers the personal data the journal collects.
  5. C055 An advertising and sponsorship policy separates commercial and editorial content.
  6. C056 There is a policy on preprints and prior publication.
  7. C057 There is a data sharing and availability policy.
  8. C058 The publisher's full contact details, including a physical address, are published.
  9. C059 Manuscripts are submitted through an online system that lets authors track progress.
  10. C060 The journal's name is not misleading and any claimed metrics are truthful.

7 Access, Archiving and Licensing

Whether published work stays available and reusable.

  1. C061 The full text of all published articles is accessible online with a permanent archive.
  2. C062 Long-term digital preservation is arranged (for example LOCKSS, CLOCKSS, PMC or a national library).
  3. C063 For open-access content, the licence (for example CC BY) is displayed on every article.
  4. C064 The full archive back to the first issue is available online.
  5. C065 Articles are available as PDF and as HTML or XML.
  6. C066 An author self-archiving policy is declared.
  7. C067 A print version or print ISSN is maintained where applicable.
  8. C068 Article URLs are stable and links are not broken.
  9. C069 Supplementary material is hosted and accessible.
  10. C070 Licence information is embedded in machine-readable form.

8 Indexing, Visibility and Identifiers

How discoverable and verifiable the journal is.

  1. C071 A valid ISSN (print and/or electronic) is registered and displayed.
  2. C072 DOIs are assigned to all articles through Crossref or a similar agency.
  3. C073 The journal is indexed in at least one recognised database (PubMed/PMC, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase or DOAJ).
  4. C074 Articles are discoverable in Google Scholar.
  5. C075 The journal is listed in national recognition lists (such as NMC or UGC-CARE) where applicable.
  6. C076 ORCID iDs are collected and displayed for authors.
  7. C077 Indexing claims on the website are accurate and verifiable.
  8. C078 Rich metadata (references, abstracts, funding) is deposited with Crossref.
  9. C079 The journal has a standard abbreviation (ISO 4 / NLM).
  10. C080 The journal is listed in discipline-specific forensic directories and databases.

9 Website and Technical Infrastructure

Quality of the journal's website and article metadata.

  1. C081 A professional, secure (HTTPS) website gives clear access to the current issue, archive and policies.
  2. C082 Each article page shows title, authors, affiliations, abstract, DOI, dates and how to cite.
  3. C083 The archive can be searched.
  4. C084 The website is mobile-friendly and accessible.
  5. C085 Citations can be exported (RIS, BibTeX or similar).
  6. C086 A standard publishing platform (such as OJS) with OAI-PMH is used.
  7. C087 Website uptime and performance are satisfactory.
  8. C088 Contact and manuscript submission links work.
  9. C089 Official correspondence uses a journal or institutional email domain.
  10. C090 Article-level metrics (views, downloads, citations) are displayed.

10 Impact, Reach and Community

Influence of the journal on research and forensic practice.

  1. C091 Articles are cited in other peer-reviewed literature, with a verifiable citation record.
  2. C092 Authorship is international.
  3. C093 Readership is geographically diverse.
  4. C094 Citation metrics (h-index, CiteScore or similar) are available and reported honestly.
  5. C095 Published work contributes to forensic practice, policy or guidelines.
  6. C096 The journal is the official organ of, or engages with, professional bodies.
  7. C097 The journal runs editor, reviewer or author training and workshops.
  8. C098 The journal reaches readers through newsletters, alerts or social media.
  9. C099 The journal collaborates with ICFJE and other journals on shared standards.
  10. C100 The journal supports early-career researchers and authors from developing countries.