ICFJE evaluation criteria
One hundred criteria in ten domains, each scored from 0 (not met) to 5 (excellent).
1 Editorial Governance and Board
Who runs the journal, how independent and qualified they are.
- C001 The Editor-in-Chief is a recognised subject expert, with full name, affiliation and verifiable credentials published.
- C002 The editorial board lists full names, designations, affiliations and countries of all members.
- C003 The board draws members from at least three institutions and includes international representation.
- C004 Board members have a demonstrable publication record in forensic medicine, forensic science or allied fields.
- C005 Roles and responsibilities of editors, section editors and board members are defined and published.
- C006 The editorial board is reviewed and renewed at defined intervals.
- C007 Ownership of the journal and the publisher or managing society are clearly stated.
- C008 Editorial decisions are demonstrably independent of owners, sponsors and advertisers.
- C009 A working editorial office contact (email and postal address) is published and responds to queries.
- C010 Editors and board members declare their competing interests.
2 Peer Review Process
How rigorously and transparently manuscripts are reviewed.
- C011 Every research article undergoes documented peer review by at least two independent external reviewers.
- C012 The type of peer review (single-blind, double-blind or open) is clearly stated.
- C013 Guidelines for reviewers are published.
- C014 Reviewers are selected for subject expertise and a reviewer database is maintained.
- C015 Editors and reviewers handling a manuscript have no conflict of interest with its authors.
- C016 Submission, acceptance and publication dates are displayed on each article.
- C017 Time from submission to first decision is reasonable (8 weeks or less) and disclosed.
- C018 Authors receive reviewer comments and an opportunity to respond to them.
- C019 An appeals and complaints process for editorial decisions is published.
- C020 Reviewers are acknowledged, for example by an annual list or recognised reviewer credit.
3 Publication Ethics and Integrity
Adherence to COPE/ICMJE principles and handling of misconduct.
- C021 The journal explicitly follows COPE and ICMJE recommendations.
- C022 All submissions are screened for plagiarism with a named tool and a stated similarity policy.
- C023 Ethics committee approval and informed consent are required for human, animal and cadaveric research.
- C024 There is a policy on confidentiality and anonymisation of case reports, autopsy and medico-legal data.
- C025 Authorship criteria and contributor roles are defined.
- C026 Conflict of interest and funding statements are required for every article.
- C027 Corrections, retractions and expressions of concern are handled and published following COPE.
- C028 There is a policy for handling data fabrication, falsification, image manipulation and other misconduct.
- C029 There is a policy on the use of AI tools by authors, reviewers and editors.
- C030 There is no evidence of predatory practices such as spam solicitation, guaranteed acceptance or fake metrics.
4 Publishing Regularity and Timeliness
Whether the journal appears on schedule and without gaps.
- C031 Issues have been published on the stated schedule, without gaps, for the last three years.
- C032 The publication frequency is clearly declared.
- C033 The journal has a continuous publication history of at least two years.
- C034 The number of articles per issue and per year is consistent, without unexplained spikes.
- C035 Every issue in the archive is complete; there are no empty or missing issues.
- C036 Accepted articles are published within a reasonable time (six months or less).
- C037 An online-first or ahead-of-print policy is stated where applicable.
- C038 Special issues have a guest-editor policy and follow the same review standards.
- C039 Volume and issue numbering is consistent.
- C040 The journal publishes an annual editorial or report on its performance.
5 Scientific Quality and Forensic Relevance
Quality of published science and its fit with forensic disciplines.
- C041 Published content falls clearly within forensic medicine, forensic science, toxicology, medical law or allied sciences.
- C042 Aims and scope are precisely defined and matched by the published content.
- C043 Original research makes up a substantial share (50% or more) of published content.
- C044 Articles show sound methodology, appropriate statistics and conclusions supported by data.
- C045 Abstracts are structured and informative, and keywords are provided.
- C046 References are current, relevant and correctly formatted.
- C047 Reporting guidelines (CONSORT, STROBE, CARE, PRISMA and similar) are recommended or enforced.
- C048 Language editing and copy-editing are of high quality.
- C049 Authors come from many institutions and regions, not mainly from the board or one institution.
- C050 Journal self-citation is within reasonable limits.
6 Transparency, Policies and Author Guidance
Clarity of the rules authors and readers rely on.
- C051 Comprehensive instructions for authors are published (article types, format, referencing).
- C052 All fees (APC, submission, fast-track) are declared before submission, with a waiver policy.
- C053 Copyright and licensing terms are clearly stated.
- C054 A privacy statement covers the personal data the journal collects.
- C055 An advertising and sponsorship policy separates commercial and editorial content.
- C056 There is a policy on preprints and prior publication.
- C057 There is a data sharing and availability policy.
- C058 The publisher's full contact details, including a physical address, are published.
- C059 Manuscripts are submitted through an online system that lets authors track progress.
- C060 The journal's name is not misleading and any claimed metrics are truthful.
7 Access, Archiving and Licensing
Whether published work stays available and reusable.
- C061 The full text of all published articles is accessible online with a permanent archive.
- C062 Long-term digital preservation is arranged (for example LOCKSS, CLOCKSS, PMC or a national library).
- C063 For open-access content, the licence (for example CC BY) is displayed on every article.
- C064 The full archive back to the first issue is available online.
- C065 Articles are available as PDF and as HTML or XML.
- C066 An author self-archiving policy is declared.
- C067 A print version or print ISSN is maintained where applicable.
- C068 Article URLs are stable and links are not broken.
- C069 Supplementary material is hosted and accessible.
- C070 Licence information is embedded in machine-readable form.
8 Indexing, Visibility and Identifiers
How discoverable and verifiable the journal is.
- C071 A valid ISSN (print and/or electronic) is registered and displayed.
- C072 DOIs are assigned to all articles through Crossref or a similar agency.
- C073 The journal is indexed in at least one recognised database (PubMed/PMC, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase or DOAJ).
- C074 Articles are discoverable in Google Scholar.
- C075 The journal is listed in national recognition lists (such as NMC or UGC-CARE) where applicable.
- C076 ORCID iDs are collected and displayed for authors.
- C077 Indexing claims on the website are accurate and verifiable.
- C078 Rich metadata (references, abstracts, funding) is deposited with Crossref.
- C079 The journal has a standard abbreviation (ISO 4 / NLM).
- C080 The journal is listed in discipline-specific forensic directories and databases.
9 Website and Technical Infrastructure
Quality of the journal's website and article metadata.
- C081 A professional, secure (HTTPS) website gives clear access to the current issue, archive and policies.
- C082 Each article page shows title, authors, affiliations, abstract, DOI, dates and how to cite.
- C083 The archive can be searched.
- C084 The website is mobile-friendly and accessible.
- C085 Citations can be exported (RIS, BibTeX or similar).
- C086 A standard publishing platform (such as OJS) with OAI-PMH is used.
- C087 Website uptime and performance are satisfactory.
- C088 Contact and manuscript submission links work.
- C089 Official correspondence uses a journal or institutional email domain.
- C090 Article-level metrics (views, downloads, citations) are displayed.
10 Impact, Reach and Community
Influence of the journal on research and forensic practice.
- C091 Articles are cited in other peer-reviewed literature, with a verifiable citation record.
- C092 Authorship is international.
- C093 Readership is geographically diverse.
- C094 Citation metrics (h-index, CiteScore or similar) are available and reported honestly.
- C095 Published work contributes to forensic practice, policy or guidelines.
- C096 The journal is the official organ of, or engages with, professional bodies.
- C097 The journal runs editor, reviewer or author training and workshops.
- C098 The journal reaches readers through newsletters, alerts or social media.
- C099 The journal collaborates with ICFJE and other journals on shared standards.
- C100 The journal supports early-career researchers and authors from developing countries.