ICFJEInternational Consortium of Forensic Journal Editors

Consortium Factor (CF)

An open, peer-led rating of forensic journals, published by the International Consortium of Forensic Journal Editors.

How it works

Every reviewer evaluates the journal on the full ICFJE checklist of 100 criteria, scoring each from 0 to 5. The average of all the reviewers' ratings is the journal's Consortium Factor.

How to write a Consortium Factor

CF23-3.58

The number after CF is the number of reviewers who evaluated the journal; the number after the dash is the average score out of 5. CF23-3.58 means the journal was evaluated by 23 reviewers on all 100 criteria and its average came out to be 3.58.

The factor grows as more reviews are published: CF5, CF23, CF76 and so on. When quoting it, give the full form exactly as shown on the journal's ICFJE page, optionally with the year, e.g. CF23-3.58 (2026).

Milestones

CF10

The journal has been evaluated by at least 10 reviewers. This is the first major milestone and the minimum for a robust rating.

CF100

The journal has been evaluated by at least 100 reviewers, the highest milestone of confidence.

CFSAJ10: Self Assessment of Journal

The journal itself picks the 10 criteria it considers its strongest. Its CFSAJ10 is the average score the reviewers gave on exactly those 10 criteria, written for example CFSAJ10-4.12. It shows whether the journal is as strong as it claims to be where it claims to be strong.

Scoring scale

ScoreMeaning
0Not met / no evidence
1Poor
2Partially met
3Satisfactory
4Good
5Excellent

Rating bands

Who reviews

Every journal has a Review button: any registered member can submit an open review independently. ICFJE also assigns a review committee to each journal (selected members or the Governing Council) whose reviews are marked as committee reviews. Each person reviews a journal once, and nobody reviews a journal they edit. Every review is checked by an ICFJE administrator before it counts towards the factor.

The ten evaluation domains

  1. Editorial Governance and Board – Who runs the journal, how independent and qualified they are.
  2. Peer Review Process – How rigorously and transparently manuscripts are reviewed.
  3. Publication Ethics and Integrity – Adherence to COPE/ICMJE principles and handling of misconduct.
  4. Publishing Regularity and Timeliness – Whether the journal appears on schedule and without gaps.
  5. Scientific Quality and Forensic Relevance – Quality of published science and its fit with forensic disciplines.
  6. Transparency, Policies and Author Guidance – Clarity of the rules authors and readers rely on.
  7. Access, Archiving and Licensing – Whether published work stays available and reusable.
  8. Indexing, Visibility and Identifiers – How discoverable and verifiable the journal is.
  9. Website and Technical Infrastructure – Quality of the journal's website and article metadata.
  10. Impact, Reach and Community – Influence of the journal on research and forensic practice.

Read all 100 criteria