ICFJEInternational Consortium of Forensic Journal Editors

← All terms and conditions

Member Terms

Version 1 · effective 27 Oct 2026

These terms apply to every Member of ICFJE (free registration). They apply in addition to the General Terms of Use.

1. Membership

Free membership lets you see the domain-by-domain evaluation of journals, submit open reviews, apply to list a journal and manage your account. Membership is personal and free of charge. ICFJE may change the features of free membership.

2. Open reviews

  • You may submit one review per journal. You must rate all 100 criteria honestly, from your own knowledge of the journal, using the published scale of 0 to 5.
  • You must not review a journal where you have a conflict of interest: for example where you are, or in the last three years were, its editor, editorial board member, publisher, employee, or where you have a financial or close personal relationship with it.
  • You must not accept or ask for anything in return for a review, and must not review under another person's name.
  • Your review is checked by an administrator before it counts toward the Consortium Factor. ICFJE may decline, edit for errors, unpublish or delete it, and may suspend accounts that misuse reviews.
  • Your name may be shown with your published review unless ICFJE decides to publish reviews without names.

3. Communications

We send you emails needed to run your account (for example password resets and decisions). We do not send marketing on behalf of third parties.

4. Requests for another role

If you asked to join as a journal editor, reviewer or Governing Council member, you remain a Member until an administrator approves the request. When a role is assigned, you must accept that role's terms.