These terms apply to every journal listed in or submitted to the ICFJE index, and to the publisher, owner or editor who submits or manages it (the "Publisher"). They apply in addition to the General Terms of Use.
1. Eligibility
- The journal must be peer-reviewed and have a clearly defined editorial and review process.
- It must be relevant to forensic science, forensic medicine, judicial expertise, legal medicine or related interdisciplinary fields.
- It must have a valid ISSN and must have been published regularly for at least one year or two consecutive issues.
2. Submission
- The Publisher confirms that it is authorised to submit the journal and that all information given is true and complete.
- Full issues or sample articles, the journal website and its online archive must be available for evaluation.
- Journal metadata (titles, abstracts, keywords, affiliations and DOIs where applicable) must be accurate.
3. Ethical standards
- Journals must follow international publishing ethics, including COPE guidelines.
- Plagiarism, data fabrication, predatory practices, fake impact claims and other misconduct lead to rejection or delisting.
- Articles must state conflicts of interest, funding sources and authorship responsibilities.
4. Evaluation and the Consortium Factor
Journals are evaluated against the 100 published ICFJE criteria. Each reviewer scores every criterion from 0 to 5. The Consortium Factor is written CFn-x.xx, where n is the number of approved reviews and x.xx is their average score (for example CF23-3.58). CF10 and CF100 are milestones. The journal's own 10 chosen criteria give its CFSAJ10 score. Reviews come from committee reviewers and from members (open reviews); every review is approved by an administrator before it counts.
The Publisher must not offer any payment, gift or favour to a reviewer, council member or administrator, must not ask anyone to rate the journal, and must not rate its own journal. Doing so leads to removal of the affected reviews and may lead to delisting.
5. Fast-track evaluation
A Publisher may order paid fast-track evaluation. Fast track changes only the order in which a journal is evaluated. It does not change the criteria, the reviewers' independence, the result or the decision to list the journal. The fee is not refundable once evaluation has started. If an application is rejected before evaluation starts, ICFJE may refund the fee less payment charges.
6. Decisions
Decisions on inclusion are made by the ICFJE Governing Council or its appointed reviewers. ICFJE may decline or delist a journal and need not give reasons. Accepted journals are listed publicly.
7. Journal homepage on ICFJE
The journal's editors may update its ICFJE homepage. They are responsible for its accuracy and must not use it for misleading claims. ICFJE may edit or remove content. The Publisher permits ICFJE to display the journal's name, logo, ISSN, editor details and links on the website and in ICFJE reports.
8. Use of the ICFJE name and CF
The Publisher may display its current Consortium Factor and ICFJE listing with a link to its ICFJE page. It must show the CF exactly as published, must not show an out-of-date or rounded-up value, and must not suggest that ICFJE endorses the journal. Certificates are valid only for the date shown on them.
9. Ongoing compliance
The Publisher must tell ICFJE of major changes in ownership, title, ISSN, editorial board, policy or frequency. Listed journals are reviewed periodically and may be suspended or removed if they no longer meet these standards.
10. Data use
Information submitted for indexing is used for evaluation and for the public index, as described in the Privacy Policy. It is never sold.